top of page

Who is a scientist? Part I - what does it mean to be a scientist in the modern world?

Feb 13, 2025
5 min read

"What does a scientist mean, uncle?"

I was about 9 years old when I asked this question to my uncle. My uncle, a speech scientist, would often read science books for kids to me and my brother, explain different aspects of the world around us, quench our curiosity while simultaneously increasing it, explain his job the best he could and so on. That day, he was talking to us about genetic engineering because an article in the news mentioned a debate about genetically modified crops. We were curious to see what DNA actually was, what do people do when they say they are scientists and in our childish naivety, we wondered if Frankenstein rats and freaky lab experiments were happening in those huge science buildings.

To quench our curiosity (and dispel our fears as well I guess!) our uncle took us to the university he worked at, and had some colleagues show us a chemistry lab, and the biochemistry department. Here we got a glimpse of the karyotyping process and first hand saw chromosomes. To me that wonder would never go away. Here we were, actually looking at a piece of the DNA that my uncle had told us about! And as a bonus, our guide also let us watch a genomic DNA extraction experiment from a cheek swab! My 9 year old self was beyond amazed. Our guide explained to us that they were ensuring that people had the right kind of DNA. I now know that they were doing routine karyotyping and mutation analysis for their cell lines. That day, I went to bed convinced that I wanted to be a scientist when I grew up. Little did I know what that even meant.

A example karyotype of a patient with trisomy 9. Each little white, black and gray band is a single chromosome. On the top is the unscrambled raw image and below is the processed image. A technician sorts and segregates each of the banded strips into its respective number. Normal humans have 22 pairs of chromosomes and a single X and a single Y (for men, as here), or a pair of X (for women). In this karyotype however, the patient is seen having 3 copies of chromosome 9, leading to Trisomy 9, a rare disorder giving rise to developmental delays and also result in death at childhood!
A example karyotype of a patient with trisomy 9. Each little white, black and gray band is a single chromosome. On the top is the unscrambled raw image and below is the processed image. A technician sorts and segregates each of the banded strips into its respective number. Normal humans have 22 pairs of chromosomes and a single X and a single Y (for men, as here), or a pair of X (for women). In this karyotype however, the patient is seen having 3 copies of chromosome 9, leading to Trisomy 9, a rare disorder giving rise to developmental delays and also result in death at childhood!

Two decades later, with a PhD in biochemistry and three postdoctoral experiences in neuroscience, I find myself asking the same question my 9 year old self wondered - what does it mean to be a scientist? Since my initial visit to my uncle's colleague's lab, science has progressed significantly, leading to numerous technological advancements in our daily lives, health, and wellness. At the fundamental level, science operates as a quest to understanding the world around us. Millions of labs around the world have established and budding researchers working to simplify life, understand the nature of the universe, improve the quality of living, and also solve major global problems such as epidemic, pandemics, global warming and energy crisis, to name a few.

Starting out on my scientific journey, I observed that science has many handles, with physics, chemistry and biology forming the main arms of science, while mathematics is usually considered a tool that progresses understanding within science (and other fields). Scientific research naturally, is similarly multifaceted. The scientific community at large is forever growing and expanding with new niches being formed every few years. For instance, twenty years back, artificial intelligence was a very small section of research conducted in remote labs, but largely just an idea of advancement in science, often elaborated in sci-fi novels. However today, AI runs a large portion of our daily lives, has become an integral part of any research and people are even suggesting AI to have a separate category for awards for scientific research. As our understanding of the world around us grows, so do advancements in science and technology. But to define scientist and scientific research we have to understand the deterministic and disciplined process that drives it. Some words scientists associate with their work are reason, meticulous, creative, curiosity driven, rigorous, logical and so on.

Driven by curiosity, scientific research allows us to question and understand the world we live in, with an unassuming nature, but in a very principled and logical manner.

Although I have formed my own perception of what it means to be a scientist, defining science within strict boundaries is challenging. Science influences everything around us, from healthcare and medicine to technology, agriculture, the food industry, transportation, architecture, banking, and environmental progress. In each of these areas, advancements adhere to a distinct scientific approach.

In the healthcare sector, scientific research traditionally begins in laboratories and research institutions (academia). From there, advancements move into industries like pharmaceutical or technological companies, which aim to develop large-scale solutions to improve our lives based on foundational research. Subsequently, regulatory bodies comb through the research work with established policies to ensure the solution developed by the industries meet established standards. New drugs or treatments typically undergo extensive preclinical and clinical trials, ensuring efficacy and safety of the novel drug before finally entering the clinics and finally patients. The figure below simplifies this pathway to emphasize the key sectors. The nature of scientific research varies significantly throughout this pathway—the rules, protocols, and specific focal points differ greatly within each sector.



Various sectors that form the bench to bedside journey within the healthcare sectors. The nature of research within each sector varies significantly, and the scientific language and jargons used in each sector sometimes are unique to that sector only. All sectors interact with one another in some form, or through the means of other sectors. While very often these communications result in successful discoveries, sometimes the difference in scientific jargons spoken within a sector can become a great hindrance in effective communication. Regulatory bodies play a major role in this entire scheme, and is the final determinant in a drug reaching patients. It is advised to involve regulatory practices as early on during the process as possible so that GCP (good clinical practices) can be followed throughout the process.
Various sectors that form the bench to bedside journey within the healthcare sectors. The nature of research within each sector varies significantly, and the scientific language and jargons used in each sector sometimes are unique to that sector only. All sectors interact with one another in some form, or through the means of other sectors. While very often these communications result in successful discoveries, sometimes the difference in scientific jargons spoken within a sector can become a great hindrance in effective communication. Regulatory bodies play a major role in this entire scheme, and is the final determinant in a drug reaching patients. It is advised to involve regulatory practices as early on during the process as possible so that GCP (good clinical practices) can be followed throughout the process.


Having been a researcher within 'pure science' (academic) sector for almost a decade now, my understanding of scientific research is that of a platform where, within limits, we can explore the very basic nature of our world with curiosity driven questions - why do we get a cold? How does a virus attack a host cell? What happens during fetal development? Such open broad questions help advance towards subsequent treatments - we can develop vaccines for COVID, utilize viruses as delivery agents to ensure drugs reach where they need to, and help solve developmental issues in children.


Join me in my next blog post as I probe deeper into the question of how scientist operate and also have expert opinions of other researchers within different stages of academia about their understanding of what being a scientist means to them.

 
 
 

Comments


Feel free to reach out with ideas and suggestions!

Disclaimer: I am a postdoctoral researcher and have been doing research on various neurological conditions for the past six years. The posts on this blog are my opinions and permitted representations of opinions of others such as scientists, industrialists, clinicians, doctors and so on. Opinions of others are always accounted for. All posts are meant for informational use and posts on this blog should not be considered as medical or wellness advice.  Please be kind and human and acknowledge any content you take away from this blog. 

bottom of page